189 Magnolia St
San Francisco · Marina · San Francisco · Coordinates: 37.80039, -122.43421
Executive Verdict · Public-Records Synthesis
Zoned NC-3 in San Francisco with likely ministerial ADU eligibility and zero mapped flood, fire, or fault hazard overlaps; benchmark value $2,292,000 ($1,948,000–$2,636,000).
Upsides & Opportunities
- ✓ Ministerial ADU / JADU pathway likely eligible
Zone NC-3 allows residential use qualifying for ministerial ADU review under state law (5 ADU permits permitted within ¼ mile in 36 months).
Source: San Francisco zoning · CA Gov. Code 66314
- ✓ Documented permitted upgrades (+$292,075 contributory est.)
Public building records show issued construction/renovation work on this parcel (5 total permits, latest Oct 20, 2026).
Source: San Francisco Department of Building Inspection, Building Permits (parcel APN)
- ✓ Above-average reinvestment in Marina
497 substantial renovation & housing permits over 24 months (120.5 per 1,000 parcels vs. 91.4 citywide baseline) (#22 of 37 neighborhoods).
Source: San Francisco Department of Building Inspection, Building Permits (Marina)
Watchouts & Due Diligence
- ! Mapped flood awareness zone (Zone X: minimal flood hazard)
all of the lot of the parcel intersects Zone X: minimal flood hazard. Outside mandatory federal SFHA insurance rules, but check local drainage and finished-floor requirements.
Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer (parcel polygon)
- ! Delayed or open permit activity on this parcel
6 new homes at 189 Magnolia St: Active in "Issued" for 9.8 yr (first record Jan 19, 2017) with no new permit activity recorded in 3.4 yr. High-impact scale (6 housing units, $1,438,075 declared valuation across 5 permits).
Source: San Francisco Department of Building Inspection, Building Permits (review-time benchmark)
- ! 4 slow or stalled nearby projects within ½ mile
Closest lead: 4 new homes (180 ft SW, entitled). Inspect timeline history before assuming near-term completion.
Source: San Francisco Department of Building Inspection, Building Permits · HCD APR (½-mile radius)
- ! Year 1 Prop 13 tax reset (~$27,496/yr at $2,292,000)
Sale triggers reassessment to 1.00% base + ~0.18% voter debt (~$2,291/mo). Confirm exact Mello-Roos / CFD special assessments on the county tax bill.
Source: CA Const. Art. XIIIA (Prop 13) · County Tax Collector
Parcel & Assessor
- Lot size:
- —
- Assessor use:
- —
- Addresses on lot:
- 189 MAGNOLIA ST
Zoning & Land Use
NC-3 — NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL, MODERATE SCALE (Mixed Use)
State Housing Pathways Screen (ADU & SB 9)
- ADU or junior ADULikely eligible
Zoned NC-3 (mixed use): state law allows ADUs where homes are allowed. On a multifamily lot the state allowance is different: ADUs in non-living space of the building, plus up to eight detached ADUs.
- SB 9: two homes on the lotUnlikely
Zoned NC-3 (mixed use), not a single-family residential zone.
- SB 9: split into two lotsUnlikely
Zoned NC-3 (mixed use), not a single-family residential zone.
Mapped Hazard Zones on This Lot
- CAL FIRE Fire Hazard Severity Zone
- Not in a State-mapped fire hazard severity zone
- FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer
- Zone X: minimal flood hazard (all of the lot) · FIRM panel 0602980116A, effective March 23, 2021
- CGS Alquist-Priolo Earthquake Fault Zone
- Not in an Alquist-Priolo Earthquake Fault Zone
Surrounding Rent & Value Benchmarks (Public Records)
Range: $1,948,000 – $2,636,000 · Status: Off market
HUD Metro FMR (San Francisco, CA HUD Metro FMR Area) · FY 2026
Studio $2,485 · 1BR $2,977 · 2BR $3,604 · 3BR $4,604 · 4BR $4,772
Nearby Activity (½ mile radius, since November 2024)
27 active or recent development projects (35 housing units across completed, permitted, and pipeline stages) and 1,410 total building permits recorded within ½ mile.
- New construction1 permit
- Adds housing (ADU)
Developments Deserving Closer Investigation & Active Area Builders
- 6 new homes at 189 Magnolia St (Issued)On this parcel
Active in "Issued" for 9.8 yr (first record Jan 19, 2017) with no new permit activity recorded in 3.4 yr. High-impact scale (6 housing units, $1,438,075 declared valuation across 5 permits).
- Remodel / interior alteration (201701197470) (reinstated)On this parcel
Issued after 22 mo — slower than 90% of remodel / interior alteration permits in San Francisco (median 1d, 90th pct 108d, n=31,105).
- 4 new homes (Entitled)180 ft SW
Active in "Entitled" for 2.2 yr (first record Aug 16, 2024) with no new permit activity recorded in 2.2 yr. High-impact scale (4 housing units across 0 permits).
- New home at 2928 Laguna St (Issued)0.26 mi SE
Active in "Issued" for 3 yr (first record Oct 31, 2023) with no new permit activity recorded in 16 mo. High-impact scale (1 housing unit, $1,342,572 declared valuation across 4 permits).
Permit & Project History on This Parcel (5 permits, 1 grouped projects)
| Record # | Category | Status | Applied / Issued | Valuation | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 202610089213 | Remodel / interior alteration | issued | Iss. Oct 20, 2026 | $800,000 | recommencement and completion of work approved under approved permit 201701197470, 202410253749. |
| 202610089211 | Remodel / interior alteration | filed | App. Oct 8, 2026 | $75,900 | commencement of work not started under pa 202507281705. |
| 202507281705 | Remodel / interior alteration | issued | Iss. Jul 28, 2025 | $75,900 | install new fire sprinikler system per npa 13 throughout the building including dedicated 2" fire service dedicated per … |
| 202410253749 | Plan revision / deferred submittal | issued | Iss. Oct 28, 2024 |